372 Reviews
Write a Review372 Reviews of Craig Rotter
February 08, 2020
Just purchased our 6th car here and wouldn’t consider anywhere else. Our salesman Phil is knowledgeable and honest. Best of all, no hidden fees. anywhere else. Our salesman Phil is knowledgeable and honest. Best of all, no hidden fees. More
Other Employees Tagged: Vin Vergara, Phil Puleo, Kenny Davis
February 06, 2020
Quick service visit Had a great experience at Wantagh Mazda. Brought my CX9 in for an oil change. Was in and out in less than an hour for an oil change and 10,000 mile se Had a great experience at Wantagh Mazda. Brought my CX9 in for an oil change. Was in and out in less than an hour for an oil change and 10,000 mile service. The service advisor, Craig, could not have been nicer. He even offered a coupon for 10% off my service. More
February 02, 2020
Great experience Absolutely wonderful service, attentive, friendly and competent from Craig and the entire service staff. I intend to service my car at Wantagh Mazda e Absolutely wonderful service, attentive, friendly and competent from Craig and the entire service staff. I intend to service my car at Wantagh Mazda exclusively because of this excellent experience even as I did not purchase the car at this dealership. So much more professional than the other Long Island dealership by purchased my car from. More
January 29, 2020
Like clockwork I can always count on Wantagh Mazda to the work right as promised. They are super honest and I always know exactly what I’m paying for. I pass by 2 other Mazda dealerships on my way to Wantag work right as promised. They are super honest and I always know exactly what I’m paying for. I pass by 2 other Mazda dealerships on my way to Wantagh because it’s worth it. I usually see Craig who is always looking out for me and makes sure that I get whatever I need. Please mute to deal with this dealership. More
January 21, 2020
RARE TO FIND A DEALERSHIP THIS GOOD Leased a Mazda 6 with them. Always felt fairly treated. David Chiari handled the sale and made sure everything went through quickly and smoothly. A lo Leased a Mazda 6 with them. Always felt fairly treated. David Chiari handled the sale and made sure everything went through quickly and smoothly. A low pressure family owned auto dealership as opposed to dealing with the megastore dealers and a pleasure to deal with. Always returned calls promptly. Scheduled services were well done and a loaner car was available. Pricing was within the expected range. Service writers explained all the points covered. Looks like I will be buying Mazas for quite while. More
Other Employees Tagged: David Chiari, Joe Stella , Gary Gavin, Alex
January 20, 2020
Honest, excellent service! Gary and Craig are always so courteous and helpful. They clearly describe what needs to be done, and never try to "hard sell" any services – you can t Gary and Craig are always so courteous and helpful. They clearly describe what needs to be done, and never try to "hard sell" any services – you can trust that what they recommend you actually need. Appointment times are adhered to and their estimated time almost always is on the mark (if not earlier). More
Other Employees Tagged: Gary Gavin
January 18, 2020
Prompt and courteous service! Craig was pleasant to work with, and without any prompting, he buffed out some scratches on my door at no further cost. I felt very taken care of and am pleased with the custom with, and without any prompting, he buffed out some scratches on my door at no further cost. I felt very taken care of and am pleased with the customer service here. More
January 10, 2020
Wantagh Mazda is the best! This is my 3rd purchase with Wantagh Mazda and each time has been a pleasure. My first purchase was in 2014 I bought my daughter a used Mazda 3. This is my 3rd purchase with Wantagh Mazda and each time has been a pleasure. My first purchase was in 2014 I bought my daughter a used Mazda 3. I came back in 2017 and leased the CX-5 for myself and now this Christmas, I upgraded to the CX-9. The whole team is extremely professional and my salesman Phil Puleo made me feel like family! There is no nonsense, straight forward negotiating and the car was prepped and ready on time. Today I had to bring my car into the service department for a minor door hinge issue and Craig Rotter took care of me immediately. He fixed the problem and I was on my way to work in less than 5 minutes! More
Other Employees Tagged: Phil Puleo, Victor Liantonio, Kenny Davis
January 06, 2020
Great dealership for buying and service I love this place. I leased my 2015 3 from here when another dealership had a great deal for me but it fell through when they couldn't take stock of I love this place. I leased my 2015 3 from here when another dealership had a great deal for me but it fell through when they couldn't take stock of the car. They called Wantagh Mazda who was willing to match the deal and they had stock of the car. Everything about picking up the car was smooth and friendly. Ever since, I've been coming to get service for my car. For my whole life, I have associated dealerships with overpriced and overserviced visits. I gave this place a chance because of the good reviews on google, yelp, etc and really glad I did. First, they get me in and out so fast. Since I always wait at the dealership, this means a lot. Second, they have to tell me I DON'T need brakes or tires when I start thinking I might. A lot of places will just say you do need to replace if you utter the words "tires" or "brakes". I still don't let them do my air filters. Way overpriced for something I can do myself. But that brings me to point number three. The prices on the things I won't do myself are reasonable enough to disregard the dealership premium and just get things done here. I'm the type that will call around and shop online to bring the parts to the cheapest place I can find. I don't have to do that here. A couple of bonus facts - they will give you a free oil change after doing 4 or 5 paid. There is a diner across the street that is pretty decent, so try to time things around lunch for less down time. Thanks Craig! More
January 01, 2020
Wantagh Mazda is really like extended family. Whether I'm purchasing a vehicle or just coming in for service the entire staff is always warm and friendly. I've personally dealt with Joe B with many vehicles purchasing a vehicle or just coming in for service the entire staff is always warm and friendly. I've personally dealt with Joe B with many vehicles and he's always honest and very professional. More
Other Employees Tagged: Phil Puleo, Kenny Davis, Joe Bonavita , Gary Gavin
Dealership Inventory (241 Vehicles)

