
38 Reviews
Write a Review38 Reviews of Mike Wagner
August 30, 2025
Barry Brash, Mike Wagner, and Brett were awesome to work with!! They were knowledgeable, quick to reply with any questions, and made our car buying experience stress-free!! I highly recommend them for all with!! They were knowledgeable, quick to reply with any questions, and made our car buying experience stress-free!! I highly recommend them for all your car buying needs!! More
Other Employees Tagged: Brett Bales, Barry Brash
August 30, 2025
Had a great experience with Barry Brash and Mike Wagner helping me pick out the right car! Brett made it nice and easy for the paperwork helping me pick out the right car! Brett made it nice and easy for the paperwork More
Other Employees Tagged: Brett Bales, Barry Brash
June 04, 2025
Mike was very personable and easy to work with. He was not my assigned salesperson, but stepped in when he was needed. I would not hesitate to recommend him to friends and family. He was not my assigned salesperson, but stepped in when he was needed. I would not hesitate to recommend him to friends and family. More
Other Employees Tagged: Tony Overkamp
July 23, 2024
Rude employee who interrupted me multiple times after discussing price. I wanted to write about my experience at Pappas Toyota and specifically with the employee “Smilin’” Mike Wagner. I put a deposit do discussing price. I wanted to write about my experience at Pappas Toyota and specifically with the employee “Smilin’” Mike Wagner. I put a deposit down on a used car over the phone and went in a few days later to look at it. Once I was satisfied with the vehicle, I went into Mike’s office to discuss price. I told him what I wanted to pay and he became very rude and standoffish afterwards, telling me I wasted his time with such a lowball offer and “made him stay late” (which I made it clear in the texts that I was not likely going to buy tonight as I had to secure financing with my bank first). I told him I would like to still order one in the future but he interrupted me, said “have a nice night”, and got up to leave his office. He’s about as sleazy a car salesman as I’ve ever met, down to the ridiculous name – “Smilin’” Mike – which of course he’s only smiling until the rubber meets the road. I can’t speak for the rest of the employees, but I’d avoid this dealer simply for employing rude salespeople. After all, usually where there’s smoke, there’s fire. More
February 27, 2024
Great service department, wonderful facilities and just awful, uninspired sales people. Not that they aren't pleasant, just don't do anything other than numbers you could get online. Not a great experience awful, uninspired sales people. Not that they aren't pleasant, just don't do anything other than numbers you could get online. Not a great experience at all. More
April 18, 2023
Mike sold me a Highlander. He was very nice and professional When I come in for an oil change he always comes by and says hello and asks me how things are going. He was very nice and professional When I come in for an oil change he always comes by and says hello and asks me how things are going. More