Many of you know Mike from having purchased 1,2,3 or more vehicles from him over the last 25 years. It is a long time to be under one roof Mike likes it when old friends and new stop by to say Hi so if you are in the area, please do so!
Read moreDealership Experience
29 yrs
Industry Experience
29 yrs
Specialties & Trainings
RAM Truck Expert
Jeep Expert
192 Reviews
Write a Review192 Reviews of Mike Elwell
March 18, 2026
Matt made my experience buying a car easy and fast. I would recommend anyone to go and see him. Everyone at the dealership greeted me with a smile, nothing but great personalities and great service! I I would recommend anyone to go and see him. Everyone at the dealership greeted me with a smile, nothing but great personalities and great service! I traded my car in, the process was very easy, and they had me in a new car within an hour. I will definitely be buying my next vehicle from them. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Matthew Votto, Aaron LaBelle
March 15, 2026
They were very nice and easy to communicate with. Would go back for my next vehicle Would go back for my next vehicle More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton, Matthew Votto
March 13, 2026
I had a great experience working with the dealership. The staff was friendly, professional, and took the time to answer all of my questions without making me feel pressured. They were transparent through The staff was friendly, professional, and took the time to answer all of my questions without making me feel pressured. They were transparent throughout the process and helped make everything straightforward and smooth. Overall, I felt well taken care of and appreciated how easy they made the experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Elwell
February 07, 2026
I drove 1 hour from Belgrade Maine to Newcastle to this dealership because they could get me in before anyone else and their service was awesome. Everyone there was really nice, very professional. Everyone dealership because they could get me in before anyone else and their service was awesome. Everyone there was really nice, very professional. Everyone seemed to know what they were doing. And it was, it was really nice. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton, Matthew Votto, Nate Chandler, Aaron LaBelle
January 28, 2026
had an excellent experience with the team at Key of Newcastle. From the moment I arrived, they treated me with genuine care and respect. During my service appointment, an unforeseen issue was discovere Newcastle. From the moment I arrived, they treated me with genuine care and respect. During my service appointment, an unforeseen issue was discovered, and they made sure it was resolved promptly while keeping me fully updated throughout the process. The staff consistently take the time to explain their findings, answer all of my questions, and provide clear options without any pressure. Their honest, straightforward approach to service has earned my trust. Because of their professionalism and commitment to customer care, I will continue purchasing my vehicles from Key of Newcastle and relying on them for all of my service needs. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton, Matthew Votto, Aaron LaBelle
January 18, 2026
They were ready to show the vehicle at the scheduled time and they made the process easy to purchase. and they made the process easy to purchase. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton
January 15, 2026
No inspection sticker. Insurance wasn't Explained to me. Felt patronized by some xxxxxx salesman. Was apparently put out by me needing a sticker. Insurance wasn't Explained to me. Felt patronized by some xxxxxx salesman. Was apparently put out by me needing a sticker. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton
January 11, 2026
Great crew! Took their time to work with me to find me something that I would be happy with. Definitely recommend. Took their time to work with me to find me something that I would be happy with. Definitely recommend. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Bob Throckmorton
December 08, 2025
Dependable, responsive, concerned for driver safety, prompt. Easy to get an appointment for service,covenient prompt. Easy to get an appointment for service,covenient More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan, Nate Chandler , Charles Maxcy
November 29, 2025
Great experience with the team. They made it easy and quick to get me into my new truck! They made it easy and quick to get me into my new truck! More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Callahan

