East Hills Subaru of Sayville

Holly Clark is hands down the most amazing car salesperson I’ve EVER worked with! Getting out of my truck lease was such a headache and with her support and guidance I was able to clear everything salesperson I’ve EVER worked with! Getting out of my truck lease was such a headache and with her support and guidance I was able to clear everything g up with my last dealer, wipe my hands clean and start over with a BRAND NEW PERFECT 2021 Subaru Legacy Sport!!! I didn’t think I could love a car this much and I’m so relieved and excited to finally be able to call this car mine! Holly made this process so quick and easy and painless! She’s amazing at explaining things and always makes time for her customers! I figured I was asking too much wanting all the bells and whistles but she’s a MAGICIAN and got me EVERYTHING I WANTED!!! Thank you! 🥰🤩🙏🏼🤗 More

We were referred to Donaldsons by a friend who loved how friendly they are. We were not steered wrong. Michael Chiofalo was an absolute pleasure to speak to. Extremely friendly and highly knowledgeable! He friendly they are. We were not steered wrong. Michael Chiofalo was an absolute pleasure to speak to. Extremely friendly and highly knowledgeable! He helped us not only pick out the right car for our needs, but also helped us get a great deal. After shopping around at multiple Subaru dealers his personality and professionalism won us over!! He made buying our new Crosstrek a wonderful experience. Our next car will definitely be from Donaldsons too. If you're considering a new Subaru give Michael a call! More

First time at this dealership. Zaak was friendly, professional, and efficient. He made what is sometimes an uncomfortable process very pleasant. Robert in Finance was also professional and efficient professional, and efficient. He made what is sometimes an uncomfortable process very pleasant. Robert in Finance was also professional and efficient. All in all a good experience More

Although I have had a Volkswagon experience with Donaldsons, this was my first Subaru experience with them. I chose to purchase my Subaru Forester from Donaldsons despite the distance from my home b Donaldsons, this was my first Subaru experience with them. I chose to purchase my Subaru Forester from Donaldsons despite the distance from my home because my previous experience(s) with this dealership were so positive. The salesperson, Michael, is very knowledgeable and patient with all the questions I had. I feel he really went the extra mile to explain everything and make sure I got want I wanted. I could not ask for a better experience. More

Zaak Fox was informative, friendly and very attentive to my needs. He has already followed up with me a few times since I purchased my Subaru to make sure everything was going great. I have recommended Zaak my needs. He has already followed up with me a few times since I purchased my Subaru to make sure everything was going great. I have recommended Zaak and Donaldsons to my friends. More

Holly Clark, what can I say, super friendly, super informative, made my wife and I feel like family . My wife bought a 2017 Crosstrek from them and the experience was the same. Great folks at Donalds informative, made my wife and I feel like family . My wife bought a 2017 Crosstrek from them and the experience was the same. Great folks at Donaldsons More

Mike Chiofalo and staff are the best- helpful, friendly, non-pressuring, knowledgable. Spent lots of time answering questions.And the price was right. Highly recommended! non-pressuring, knowledgable. Spent lots of time answering questions.And the price was right. Highly recommended! More

Having shopped for used cars for a few weeks for the new driver in our family, we were unable to find a good combination of clean, reliable, safe and value. We test drove a couple of decade old Imprezas w driver in our family, we were unable to find a good combination of clean, reliable, safe and value. We test drove a couple of decade old Imprezas with well over 100k miles on each and more than half the price of brand new but, we could tell they were high quality cars. We stopped by Donaldson Subaru in Sayville NY to inquire about a new one. We were eagerly greeted by Michael (I could tell he was smiling under his mask) who was welcoming and ready to take good care of us. We hit it off, he treated us like were were long time friends. No nonsense pricing eliminated the need for negotiation and we found excellent value in a new Subaru vs used ones. Michael took excellent care of us through the entire process. Others (I do know their names) who we spoke with and worked with on the purchase were very helpful and friendly. You can tell the dealership has a superior management team as everyone who works there are friendly and extremely courteous. The car was prepped perfectly, spotlessly clean and ready to go. Our new driver loves his new and most importantly safe new ride. W we will definitely recommend Donaldsons to friends and family and when it comes time for another car, they'll be at the top of our list. More

Zaak Fox was helpful and very nice. Because of him I was able to make my decision because I trusted him. I am very happy with my purchase. able to make my decision because I trusted him. I am very happy with my purchase. More