
Nick Reuther
General Manager
Beaver Toyota St. Augustine
2995 US Highway 1 S
St. Augustine, FL 32086
56 Reviews
Write a Review56 Reviews of Nick Reuther
May 13, 2025
We purchased a vehicle March 1st and have yet been able to register our vehicle because they do not actually have the title for the vehicle they sold us. We have been given the run around since around 25 d to register our vehicle because they do not actually have the title for the vehicle they sold us. We have been given the run around since around 25 days after we purchased. I am on my third temporary tag. We have been told there was a problem with the title, it’s been lost, it’s in the mail, etc. By law this should have been handled within 30 days. It was likely a slip up to have been told they were already having trouble getting the title before they sold the vehicle to us. Today we were told best case we may have the title by the end of the month. This is my 14th vehicle purchase and by far the worst experience I have ever had. If a title can not be produced we should be fully refunded especially when they have said they were having problems from the beginning obtaining the title from the auction house. I will never give any more business to a Beaver dealership if this is how little they think if their customers to constantly give them the run around. More
January 18, 2025
Thank you Gary for your professionalism, expertise, and hard work at finding a vehicle and good deal for us. We started with trying to get into a Highlander hybrid, couldn’t get that to work, moved to an R hard work at finding a vehicle and good deal for us. We started with trying to get into a Highlander hybrid, couldn’t get that to work, moved to an RAV4 hybrid, could not get that to work either,and were finally able to work a deal on a Sienna hybrid. Thank you, too to the entire Beaver team. More
Other Employees Tagged: George May, Gary Gonzales
January 06, 2025
Great experience with great people that made buying my new car easy and and a good price! new car easy and and a good price! More

Other Employees Tagged: Frank “Bee”, Oraine Brissett
December 26, 2024
This dealership is awesome. I received professional customer service from Oraine Brissett and Dave Kraus. Adrian Johnson also made my financing process go very smoothly and wit I received professional customer service from Oraine Brissett and Dave Kraus. Adrian Johnson also made my financing process go very smoothly and with less confusion as possible. The general manager Nick Reuther has a very solid team here. I highly recommend this dealership without a doubt. More
Other Employees Tagged: Dave Kraus, Cameron Shemwell, Gary Gonzales, Darryn Lewis, Isaiah Price, Sara Conklin, Charlie Dillard, Demontre Neeley, Oraine Brissett
October 14, 2024
I love Beaver Toyota. I only buy Toyota!! Oraine was a pleasure to work with. He made the whole experience enjoyable and was able get the best deal for me. I only buy Toyota!! Oraine was a pleasure to work with. He made the whole experience enjoyable and was able get the best deal for me. More
Other Employees Tagged: George May, Steven Miller, Tammy Caroul, Nancy West, Scott Boito, Art Dello Iacono, Trey Cameron, Oraine Brissett , Rodney Gonzalez
September 30, 2024
No need to go anywhere else even if its a bit of a drive. ..Mr Landon Hall is a top teir salesman as well as a product specialist. ..Mr Landon Hall is a top teir salesman as well as a product specialist. More
Other Employees Tagged: George May, Seth Cameron, Landon Hall
September 19, 2024
Great dealership as always, have been purchasing and reffering to beaver since 2007,, and of course Ned did not disappoint. Ned and his management was exceptional, went above and beyond to make sure I w reffering to beaver since 2007,, and of course Ned did not disappoint. Ned and his management was exceptional, went above and beyond to make sure I was happy, and satisfied with my vehicle throughout the entire process. Drove a hour and a half away because I knew as always they would go thoroughly above and beyond. Wonderful Dealership as always! More

Other Employees Tagged: George May, Jerry May, Ned Alnuaimi, Landon Hall , Gabriel Saling
September 18, 2024
Ned went above and beyond for me in the process. He spend hours trying to find the perfect vehicle for me for the perfect process. His service was beyond exceptional. He spend hours trying to find the perfect vehicle for me for the perfect process. His service was beyond exceptional. More
Other Employees Tagged: Jerry May, Ned Alnuaimi
August 10, 2024
I have used Beaver Toyota service and sales for several years. Every experience at Beaver Toyota has been pleasant and outstanding. I look forward to going there for service. Everyone is very friendly, years. Every experience at Beaver Toyota has been pleasant and outstanding. I look forward to going there for service. Everyone is very friendly, supportive, and hard working. Everyone has a very positive and enthusiastic attitude. In today's high stress and competitive business world, I'm not sure how everyone you meet at at Beaver Toyota can be so consistently friendly and positive. Everyone goes out of their way to make the customer feel at home. They also follow up on what they say they will do. My 2023 Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid is exceeding all my expectations; for example it's rated to get a combined 45 miles per gallon, but I consistently get between 50 and 60 miles per gallon and as much as 70 miles per gallon. Great Job Beaver Toyota. More
Other Employees Tagged: George May, Dave Kraus, Jerry May, John Fishack , Gabriel Saling, Jared (mechanic) and Douglas McKee (service advisor) - both five stars
June 06, 2024
Extremely happy with my experience at Beaver Toyota! Aaron, Nick and Robert were very helpful, patient and knowledgeable. This is my second vehicle purchase here, highly recommended! Aaron, Nick and Robert were very helpful, patient and knowledgeable. This is my second vehicle purchase here, highly recommended! More
Other Employees Tagged: Robert Madonna, Aaron Hutt
Dealership Inventory (523 Vehicles)


