New York born and raised. Lived in Florida since 1989. Been in sales for last 30 years. Believes in motto that customer is allways number 1!!
Read moreDealership Experience
8 yrs, 2 mos
Industry Experience
8 yrs, 2 mos
Specialties & Trainings
Toyota Certified
442 Reviews
Write a Review442 Reviews of Matthew Sethi
December 04, 2025
Service from sales department was horrendous from large group of sales personnel outside who looked more like they were stealing cars than selling. My salesperson pawned me off to gentleman who was totally group of sales personnel outside who looked more like they were stealing cars than selling. My salesperson pawned me off to gentleman who was totally disinterested. Was abandoned for over half hour while my car was being appraised. Then came back with a contract with no explanation. Just told sell car to carvana as they offer more. Asked for the keys which I finally received however was not told where they put the car. Had to go back to separate building to get an answer. Was a clown show from the start. Exceptionally unprofessional. More
Other Employees Tagged: Axel Torres
September 17, 2025
They where rude and communication after purchasing my vehicle there was no help or anything. This is the worst place I’ve ever dealt with. vehicle there was no help or anything. This is the worst place I’ve ever dealt with. More
Other Employees Tagged: Roger Page , Austin in fiance
August 06, 2024
At first, the experience was good. Matthew Sethi was the salesperson who assisted me with the car, and he seemed really friendly at the start. However, everything changed when I notice Matthew Sethi was the salesperson who assisted me with the car, and he seemed really friendly at the start. However, everything changed when I noticed a dent on the passenger door of a 2022 4Runner I was buying which he not disclose. He was rushing me to sign the paperwork and added accessories worth $1880 I did not ask for. He said the accessories was for floor mats, a key replacement plan, nitrogen in the tires, and window tint. He hurried me through the signing process and only handed me the details of what I had agreed to afterward. This kind of business practice is really disappointing, and I definitely won’t be returning or recommending this dealership to anyone. More
January 28, 2024
Matthew Sethi (car salesman) is a typical Car salesman. You know… the ones that will lie to you just to make a buck off you. First he told me I couldn’t pay with a cashiers check bc my bank was in another You know… the ones that will lie to you just to make a buck off you. First he told me I couldn’t pay with a cashiers check bc my bank was in another county even tho that same bank was 5 minutes down the road of their dealership and I got the cashiers check from that bank. Not mine back home. Second, he told me that if I financed I could pay it off within 2 days and the interest I would incur would be “The price of a Big Mac” and there would be no payoff charges whatsoever. He convinced me… that’s my own fault for believing a car salesman. Bc 2 days after I bought my vehicle from him I received my financing statements and when I clicked on “payoff vehicle” guess what??!! They charged me $400 extra dollars!! Now I don’t know where this man is buying a Big Mac for $400 but holy xxxx. He got me good. I mean he got me REAL good. Mostly my fault for being a sucker and believing something a car salesman says, but needless to say, they might have good prices on their vehicles but don’t trust a flippin word any of them say. Especially Matthew Sethi. More
December 13, 2023
My service guy was very kind & explained everything thoroughly. I was given a loaner car which was appreciated. thoroughly. I was given a loaner car which was appreciated. More
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Calhoun
December 09, 2023
I was lied to twice once by the salesman and once by his manager regarding the fees that I need to pay. Then I went to finance even though I was paying cash the finance gentleman told me that the extended w manager regarding the fees that I need to pay. Then I went to finance even though I was paying cash the finance gentleman told me that the extended warranty was not a third-party warranty that it was owned by Toyota,after I purchased it the next day I did research, and it was a third-party warranty, not owned by Toyota. I feel like I was lied multiple times to, and would not trust them again. More
Other Employees Tagged: Sami Pinal
July 28, 2023
The best possible service from Gil and Matthew. They worked to get our deal completed in the shortest possible time. They worked to get our deal completed in the shortest possible time. More
Other Employees Tagged: Gil Mariano

