data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5cf6f/5cf6f3fc3c8779ac5ad5c5f275f283d2c637d010" alt="Donnie McMillen at Toothman Ford"
Donnie McMillen
Sales Manager
Toothman Ford
RTE 50 West, 1569 George Washington Hwy
Grafton, WV 26354
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2888b/2888bdd2e1523766a1795d327a8d56f4ef1025b0" alt=""
A resident of Masontown, WV, Donnie has been selling Ford products for over 20 years. He enjoys spending time with his wife, Tawnya, and his boys.
Read more287 Reviews
Write a Review287 Reviews of Donnie McMillen
January 30, 2025
Horrible experience, horrible jeep, and horrible service. Purchased it in September, few days later it overheated and the engine light came on. I took it back and they said there was nothing wrong and insist Purchased it in September, few days later it overheated and the engine light came on. I took it back and they said there was nothing wrong and insisted I took it home. Few days later it’s overheating again. Had to have it towed in which they did not pay for not to mention I live an hour away. They still said nothing was wrong and tried to get me to take it home again. I refused to take it home since obviously something was definitely wrong, after 2 weeks of having it they finally said it needed a motor. They said they didn’t have a loaner for me to drive at the time so I had to pay and rent my own car until they got one in. That took 2 weeks. Once I got the loaner it was in horrible shape and definitely not safe with brake issues. Two months I finally got it. I had only driven it for one week total. So that was November 2nd, yesterday it broke down on me with several lights on. I took it to my local garage and had it repaired so I didnt have to go there again and them keep it forever. Now today 2 lights came on and here we are. 5 months and 4 different visits for repairs. Not dependable at all. I will never buy there again and would not recommend them to anyone. More
November 26, 2023
Bait and switch operation no truck available. Won't answer questions about the specific vehicle at all. High pressure data mining with repeated phone sales calls every day. "Just want to ask y Won't answer questions about the specific vehicle at all. High pressure data mining with repeated phone sales calls every day. "Just want to ask you a few questions... ". Gross. More
Other Employees Tagged: Adam Post, Sam Gerkin, Brad Summers, Danny Leach, Tyler Stevens, Keith Leach, Justin Sisler, Corey McMillen, Justin Newlon , Ashley
March 30, 2023
No return contact from dealer on potential sale of car, as is with the case with all I have contacted threw this site as is with the case with all I have contacted threw this site More
Other Employees Tagged: Adam Post, Sam Gerkin, Danny Leach, Seth Elsey, Tyler Stevens, Keith Leach, Justin Sisler, Corey McMillen, Justin Newlon
December 17, 2022
I found a vehicle I wished to purchase on line. I asked Tyler McMillen to please provide theier best price. I was quoted the full online price. I sent a return message with my counter offer and I I asked Tyler McMillen to please provide theier best price. I was quoted the full online price. I sent a return message with my counter offer and I was pretty much ghosted. I sent Tyler 3 more messages and even called the dealership with no response. I’m not complaining because I am not getting the price I wanted I am complying because Tyler wouldn’t take the time to message or call me back. Very poor customer service. More
Other Employees Tagged: Corey McMillen , Tyler McMillen
September 23, 2022
Shameful dealership looking to rip “unkowing” customers off. Well I am not that person. Sales manager Donnie got mad and hung up on me because I had access to the same websites as him. When he offered $60 off. Well I am not that person. Sales manager Donnie got mad and hung up on me because I had access to the same websites as him. When he offered $6000 ($10,000 minimum rough trade) for a $15000 retail car that only needs tires you could see my shock. Once confronted with the news that I had the same information as dealerships he became emotional and loud. He wouldn’t let me speak and hung up on me. This place is clearly crooked if this is your sales manager. Buyer beware. Pawn shop operation here. More
July 07, 2021
Great customer service. Everyone is knowledgeable and friendly! Minimal wait time from start to finish! Extremely impressed with all aspects of this dealership!! Very Happy!! friendly! Minimal wait time from start to finish! Extremely impressed with all aspects of this dealership!! Very Happy!! More
Other Employees Tagged: Keith Leach , Drew Musgrove
January 05, 2021
Another great buying experience from Adam and Toothman Ford! We were in and out in no time. We have purchased several vehicles from Adam over the years -Thanks again for treating us like family! Ford! We were in and out in no time. We have purchased several vehicles from Adam over the years -Thanks again for treating us like family! More
Other Employees Tagged: Adam Post, Keith Leach
May 12, 2020
DO NOT BUY A CAR FROM HERE. THEY SOLD ME A LEMON AND REFUSE TO FIX THINGS BECAUSE THEY KNOW THE CAR HAS SO MANY ISSUES AND THEY RESET CODES SO NO ONE WOULD FIND THEM. MY WARRANTY SHOULD COVER THINGS BUT REFUSE TO FIX THINGS BECAUSE THEY KNOW THE CAR HAS SO MANY ISSUES AND THEY RESET CODES SO NO ONE WOULD FIND THEM. MY WARRANTY SHOULD COVER THINGS BUT SINCE I HAVE FAULTY SENSORS IT CAUSED WAY MORE DAMAGE AND NOW MY CAR IS xxxxED UO AND I CANT GET IT COVERED BECAUSE THEYRE LYING TRASH More
Other Employees Tagged: Adam Post, Sam Gerkin, Brad Summers, Danny Leach, Seth Elsey, Tyler Stevens, Keith Leach, Justin Sisler, Justin Newlon
February 08, 2020
Highly recommend Great sales people and staff!!Cars Highly recommend Great sales people and staff!! Cars cost less in Grafton!! Tyler Stevens makes buying a car easy. Thank you Toothman Ford! You Highly recommend Great sales people and staff!! Cars cost less in Grafton!! Tyler Stevens makes buying a car easy. Thank you Toothman Ford! You’re awesome!! More
Other Employees Tagged: Tyler Stevens, Corey McMillen