372 Reviews
Write a Review372 Reviews of Craig Rotter
May 12, 2018
Highly recommended only dealer I will buy from Wantagh Mazda is a high volume dealership, so their prices are unmatched. Sales personnel are friendly, helpful and do not pressure potential buyers. Wantagh Mazda is a high volume dealership, so their prices are unmatched. Sales personnel are friendly, helpful and do not pressure potential buyers. In addition the service department is among the best I have ever experienced, making Wantagh Mazda the complete dealership and is highly recommended by me, my family and the many friends that have purchased vehicles there. More
Other Employees Tagged: Phil Puleo, Kenny Davis, Joe Bonavita, Josh Pena , Gary Gavin
March 31, 2018
Simply the Best Service Department is simply the best!!! Had to take car to service for inspection and oil change for a road trip. Appointments all booked up, they Service Department is simply the best!!! Had to take car to service for inspection and oil change for a road trip. Appointments all booked up, they took me in with open arms and did the work for me. Once again you guys proved to me that you still are the best.. Thank you!!! More
Other Employees Tagged: Gary Gavin, Kristie Vargas
March 16, 2018
AMAZING!!! BEST SERVICE CENTER!!! They all were a pleasure to work with!!! CRAIG- went above and beyond for me! I truly appreciated ALL of his help! BEST SERVICE CENTER!!! They all were a pleasure to work with!!! CRAIG- went above and beyond for me! I truly appreciated ALL of his help! More
Other Employees Tagged: Jennifer Lopez- was a pleasure to work with on the phone!
March 15, 2018
Always a positive experience! As a general rule, going to the car dealer is generally close to going to the dentist. But not these guys! Every time I go there, it's relaxed and t As a general rule, going to the car dealer is generally close to going to the dentist. But not these guys! Every time I go there, it's relaxed and they always exceed my expectations. Today, I went without an appointment (because I was passing by on the way home from another appointment). I was hoping to get a recall fixed, but without an appointment I really just figured it was a longshot at best. Once again, they exceed my expectations. The service tech tells the counter lady that he'll take care of my car immediately before he goes to lunch. Who does that? But at Wantagh Mazda, this has been my experience more than once. Everyone there is humble and helpful, and who can ask for more at a car dealer. Finally, a car dealer where going doesn't feel like pulling teeth! Great job Wantagh guys, again! I always recommend this dealer, and when I'm ready for another car, guess where I'll be going? More
March 09, 2018
Great Customer Service Experience! Brought my car in recently as was having some issues with brake wear that I should not have experienced. They took care of my problem in a prompt man Brought my car in recently as was having some issues with brake wear that I should not have experienced. They took care of my problem in a prompt manner, expediting the necessary parts and getting the job done quickly and efficiently. Multiple phone calls staying on top of things. Great experience!! More
March 06, 2018
Thank You! I was in a predicament this morning. I was on my way to visit my aunt in a nursing home and 3 lights came on in my car.I drove right to Wantagh Mazad I was in a predicament this morning. I was on my way to visit my aunt in a nursing home and 3 lights came on in my car.I drove right to Wantagh Mazada Service Dept. They immediately helped me and got me on the road with a brand new loaner car. I was so relieved that I was able to go about my day and visit with my aunt. Kristie Vargas quickly took charge and got me int the car and Craig Rotter called me later to let me know what the problem was and that it would be fixed within hours. I was so grateful to them and can't thank them enough for helping me out. All the people at Wantagh Mazda are awesome and had always helped me out with my service needs. I would highly recommend them! Thank You once again! More
Other Employees Tagged: Kristie Vargas
February 12, 2018
Honest Dealership I was a former Volkswagen owner and traded in my car for a Mazda. The Volkswagen service center in Hicksville, NY ripped me off and very unprofession I was a former Volkswagen owner and traded in my car for a Mazda. The Volkswagen service center in Hicksville, NY ripped me off and very unprofessional but here at Wantagh Mazda I'm very happy to be one of their customers. The service manager Gary and his team are awesome!!! They are always accommodating and resolve any issues with my vehicle on the first visit. Keep up the great job and service you provide. More
Other Employees Tagged: Joe Bonavita , Gary Gavin
February 08, 2018
Wantagh Mazda I went to Wantagh Mazda with my daughter and her boyfriend today. They were amazed as to how nice they were to us. I have bought 2 cars from them. It’ I went to Wantagh Mazda with my daughter and her boyfriend today. They were amazed as to how nice they were to us. I have bought 2 cars from them. It’s how they treat me that keeps me going back. Gary and Craig , the service manager make me feel appreciated. It’s the service that I get that keeps me going back. More
Other Employees Tagged: Kenny Davis, Joe Bonavita , Gary Gavin
February 03, 2018
Friendly, fast, easy Craig was very friendly and easy to work with! He made the process seamless and quick. He went the extra mile to make me comfortable! Craig was very friendly and easy to work with! He made the process seamless and quick. He went the extra mile to make me comfortable! More
January 29, 2018
Quick Service I was on a time crunch today because I needed to have a key fob and 55,000 mile service done. They got me out in under an hour. Thanks so much to the I was on a time crunch today because I needed to have a key fob and 55,000 mile service done. They got me out in under an hour. Thanks so much to the service Wantagh Mazda service department. They are quick courteous and professional in every aspect. More

