Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
McGrath Evanston Subaru
Skokie, IL
294 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 294 reviews
November 30, 2025
I love this dealership! I have bought 3 Subarus from McGrath-in part because of Omar Aziz. He has been incredible at getting me the car I want for the price I am looking to I have bought 3 Subarus from McGrath-in part because of Omar Aziz. He has been incredible at getting me the car I want for the price I am looking to spend. The service department is also incredible. Every time I get my car serviced, the entire staff is so kind and gracious, not all pushy. Highly recommend this dealership! More
by Katie
November 26, 2025
The moment you step into McGrath Subaru, you can feel that everyone in the dealership is there to help you. From the Service dept to the Showroom, McGrath cares about you, your Subaru experience, and you that everyone in the dealership is there to help you. From the Service dept to the Showroom, McGrath cares about you, your Subaru experience, and your satisfaction. As a customer, you want to be treated with kindness, respect, and professionalism - McGrath delivers all of that and then some. I bought in 2021 and am back for another one. This new 2025 experience was just as constantly wonderful. Do yourself a favor and buy your next car from McGrath Subaru. More
by Tmcmill8
November 23, 2025
Thank you, Brendan for continuing the stellar experience after my forester touring purchase. You provided a great service helping me understand all the bells and whistles the new 2026 model has to offer. Th after my forester touring purchase. You provided a great service helping me understand all the bells and whistles the new 2026 model has to offer. This is my 3rd consecutive purchase of a forester from Evanston Subaru. They make it easy to keep coming back - great produce, great service, and great people like Brendan! More
by janeerb1
November 22, 2025
I’ve been a McGrath Evanston Subaru customer for over 15 years and just bought my fourth Subaru from Evan and his team, a 2025 Forester Sport. The experience was smooth, fair, and respectful from start t years and just bought my fourth Subaru from Evan and his team, a 2025 Forester Sport. The experience was smooth, fair, and respectful from start to finish. The salesperson was helpful and patient, and Evan Paddor, the General Manager, went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled with care. He honored our agreed price, explained everything clearly, and treated us like family. If you’re shopping for a Subaru, I highly recommend Evan and the team at McGrath Evanston. Their professionalism and honesty are why I keep coming back. — T Stefanov More
by T Stefanov
November 19, 2025
Low pressure, great follow-up from everyone, including after the sale. Take it from someone who hates buying cars. Other dealers played the usual games, not here! after the sale. Take it from someone who hates buying cars. Other dealers played the usual games, not here! More
by Rick
November 16, 2025
Hi Brendan: Thanks for the A-to-Z walk through of our new Crosstrek, actually our eighth Subaru now. Greatly appreciated your special assist detailing all the new improvements. Five Star and thumbs up. Jim L Crosstrek, actually our eighth Subaru now. Greatly appreciated your special assist detailing all the new improvements. Five Star and thumbs up. Jim L. More
by ezjimbo
Employees Worked With
November 16, 2025
Thanks Brendan, you did a great job reviewing all the unique features of my new hybrid crosstrek. I appreciate you going the "extra mile" and installing my roof rack crossbars. unique features of my new hybrid crosstrek. I appreciate you going the "extra mile" and installing my roof rack crossbars. More
by skitiludrp
November 09, 2025
Brendan Hancock's explanation of all the features in my new Forester was exactly what I needed! I left my meeting with him confident that I understood everything I needed to know to drive comfortably and new Forester was exactly what I needed! I left my meeting with him confident that I understood everything I needed to know to drive comfortably and safely. Brendan is a wonderful member of the McGrath dealership team. More
by jjkent2
October 26, 2025
Friendly & knowledgable, the customer service is much better then other subaru dealer i bought my 1st crosstrek from, now i already bought 2 foreseters from here & i will continue to buy from this dealer better then other subaru dealer i bought my 1st crosstrek from, now i already bought 2 foreseters from here & i will continue to buy from this dealer. More
by pence3023
Employees Worked With
October 26, 2025
Quick, efficient, and was easy to work with. Was able to easily understand my needs. Was able to easily understand my needs. More
by SG
Employees Worked With
