Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Maguire Automotive
Ithaca, NY
1,081 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
1,081 Reviews of Maguire Automotive
July 13, 2021
A seamless sale. Our salesman Garrett Storm was terrific. Met us as we pulled in, he had the car ready for a test drive. Answered our questions and had a thorough understanding of the car. Quick, friendly an Met us as we pulled in, he had the car ready for a test drive. Answered our questions and had a thorough understanding of the car. Quick, friendly and efficient throughout the sale process. Scheduled a pick up time and went through the car with my wife and even set up her phone for her! We are very pleased with our purchase and the professional and personal attention paid to us by Garrett. He gets 5 stars from us. Shane and Robin More
by RGALLUP
Verified CustomerEmployees Worked With
Garrett Storm, Cody Hilsinger
July 10, 2021
Very very rude and unprofessional sales representative. he promised me that he will call me before noon and I gave him a call afternoon to check status of the car that I was planning to buy, he yelled at m he promised me that he will call me before noon and I gave him a call afternoon to check status of the car that I was planning to buy, he yelled at me and hang up on my face. More
by Armgnasln
Employees Worked With
Steve Manos
July 09, 2021
Friendly, non-pushy customer service when buying or leasing a car. I felt valued and appreciated. And I LOVE what we got!!! Yay Sienna Hybrid!! leasing a car. I felt valued and appreciated. And I LOVE what we got!!! Yay Sienna Hybrid!! More
by Katelyn
Employees Worked With
Jesse Westfall
July 09, 2021
Mike k took great care of us. Very professional and we never felt pressured. Offered to help us with some after market items. Straight shooter when it came to our trade. Thanks again Mike never felt pressured. Offered to help us with some after market items. Straight shooter when it came to our trade. Thanks again Mike More
by Irish2019
Employees Worked With
Nick Bell, Mike Kaufman, Adam Coghlan
July 07, 2021
The entire staff was friendly and I was assisted the minute I walked in for my appointment. The waiting area was clean with plenty of snacks while I waited for my car’s inspection. The car wash is a ni minute I walked in for my appointment. The waiting area was clean with plenty of snacks while I waited for my car’s inspection. The car wash is a nice plus. More
by TSW22
Employees Worked With
Wyatt , Ainslee Kearney
July 07, 2021
Deal for new car negotiated, & consummated 24 hours of Deal for new car negotiated, & consummated 24 hours of initial call. Drove long distance to get car. Did trade in, all Paperwork ready, no surprises. Deal for new car negotiated, & consummated 24 hours of initial call. Drove long distance to get car. Did trade in, all Paperwork ready, no surprises. More
by Drea
Employees Worked With
Jake shwartz, Kyle Reynolds
July 07, 2021
Clean, organized and prompt. Standard services look to be addressed well. Waiting room very nice. I had a specific suspension issue and question. After evaluation I received a summary of deficiencies, bu be addressed well. Waiting room very nice. I had a specific suspension issue and question. After evaluation I received a summary of deficiencies, but root cause was not identified. Same as the muffler place. More
by Mitchmitch55newyork
Employees Worked With
Wyatt
July 07, 2021
The dealership was very clean and sanitary. The individual who helped me buy the car (Clayton) was a very nice individual who clearly explaied everything in a timely fashion and I am very happy I w individual who helped me buy the car (Clayton) was a very nice individual who clearly explaied everything in a timely fashion and I am very happy I went to them. More
by Njohnson5
Employees Worked With
Clayton Templar
July 06, 2021
Always knowledgeable and prompt and clear and kind. They make me feel safe with my car which I drive back and forth from NY to NM. I have confidence in them make me feel safe with my car which I drive back and forth from NY to NM. I have confidence in them More
by BOYNTONV
Employees Worked With
RJ West, John VonGordon, Eric Curren, Bob Sullivan, Chelsy Carey, Ainslee Kearney
