Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Competition Subaru of Smithtown
St James, NY
591 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 591 reviews
September 09, 2020
Salesman Sean Miller was excellent ! Knowledgeable and patient , didn’t pressure me . Love my new Subaru Legacy Limited . I bought the car from the Showroom floor . Would recommend Sean and Competition patient , didn’t pressure me . Love my new Subaru Legacy Limited . I bought the car from the Showroom floor . Would recommend Sean and Competition to friends. More
by Jodi
Employees Worked With
Sea Miller 5 stars !, Reginald Watkins
September 02, 2020
Lisa was wonderful. There was no pressure, she was knowledgable, trustworthy, and I felt she was truly on my side, getting me the car I wanted in a price range I was comfortable with. Justin in financ knowledgable, trustworthy, and I felt she was truly on my side, getting me the car I wanted in a price range I was comfortable with. Justin in finance was so sweet, honest, and made the whole process quick and simple. I would recommend them to everyone. More
by Andrea
Employees Worked With
Lisa Cain, Justin Stein
August 27, 2020
Really impressive dealership. Knowledge, friendly, professional service gets a five star rating from me. Well spaced waiting area with all the amenities adds to the sense of quality and caring servi professional service gets a five star rating from me. Well spaced waiting area with all the amenities adds to the sense of quality and caring service. Liliana Hart in particular was a pleasure to deal with and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to my friends and family. More
by ReubenT
Employees Worked With
Liliana Hart
August 25, 2020
I'm so happy with this dealership. Rodney McCabe was my salesperson, so nice and got me in and out. Best car buying experience, no stress. Everyone is so friendly. Very busy place so go at an off time salesperson, so nice and got me in and out. Best car buying experience, no stress. Everyone is so friendly. Very busy place so go at an off time. Love my Imprezza and I love the price. More
by Chrissydhazard
Employees Worked With
Rodney McCabe, Christopher Pompeo
August 20, 2020
Be careful once you get to finance. Read contract carefully....not looking to get you the best deal. The numbers were higher than promised! Buyer beware carefully....not looking to get you the best deal. The numbers were higher than promised! Buyer beware More
by Loopee
Employees Worked With
Tony
August 04, 2020
new lease I came back because Joe G is wonderful to deal with. He's easygoing, he responds to my concerns within a reasonable amount of time, and seems to get I came back because Joe G is wonderful to deal with. He's easygoing, he responds to my concerns within a reasonable amount of time, and seems to get me the best deals. More
by mamasauer2005
Employees Worked With
Joseph Giampietro
August 01, 2020
Joe was great! He is so helpful and knowledgeable. Always reachable and returns calls promptly answers any question. Very helpful and considerate especially during the cOvid crisis as well. Took the time to reachable and returns calls promptly answers any question. Very helpful and considerate especially during the cOvid crisis as well. Took the time to set up car systems with us and show us how to work them. More
by donfgroup
Employees Worked With
The guy that helped with the finance paperwork etc. was terrific as well.sorry I forgot his name. Also the receptionist was lovely., Joseph Giampietro
July 18, 2020
Busy but ready to help. Felt important from the moment I walked in. No pressure to buy. Salesperson knowledgeable and personable, not pushy or arrogant. walked in. No pressure to buy. Salesperson knowledgeable and personable, not pushy or arrogant. More
by B.j.stahl
Employees Worked With
Joseph Giampietro
July 17, 2020
The service we received at Competition, but especially from Joe Giampietro, was fantastic. He didn’t try to sell us anything we didn’t need and got us a great deal. The car even came in earlier than expec from Joe Giampietro, was fantastic. He didn’t try to sell us anything we didn’t need and got us a great deal. The car even came in earlier than expected. We were very happy with the whole experience! More
by mcara28
Employees Worked With
Joseph Giampietro
July 17, 2020
My 3rd purchase from Vinny DeRenzo at Competition Dealer My 3rd purchase from Vinny DeRenzo at Competition Dealer cares that your happy with purchase and will make every effort to make sure you love the de My 3rd purchase from Vinny DeRenzo at Competition Dealer cares that your happy with purchase and will make every effort to make sure you love the dealership for service as well More
by Ronald S from Woodbury
Employees Worked With
Nash in Service, Vincent Direnzo
