Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Competition BMW of Smithtown
Smithtown, NY
1,079 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 1,079 reviews
December 19, 2017
Good customer service This my 8th BMW and the 3rd dealer I've worked with, excellent overall. However, all other dealers give a gift, got nothing, not even an umbrella! This my 8th BMW and the 3rd dealer I've worked with, excellent overall. However, all other dealers give a gift, got nothing, not even an umbrella! More
by roxbro
Employees Worked With
Wasyl Bozydaj
December 17, 2017
New 530x It was a pleasure working with Jason and he handled everything quickly and easily. He handled the deal in a profesional manner. Hands down the best ca It was a pleasure working with Jason and he handled everything quickly and easily. He handled the deal in a profesional manner. Hands down the best car buying experince I have ever had. Not only did he listen to my families need but he provided us with fair price! Addtionaly he guided us to a color selection that is breath taking! More
by gmorris1017
Employees Worked With
Jospeh Saint-Val, Jason Phelps
December 16, 2017
Great overall experience!!! Great experience during the sales process and during final pickup! I never felt any sales pressure from Marc. Great communications during the whole p Great experience during the sales process and during final pickup! I never felt any sales pressure from Marc. Great communications during the whole process. Helga was quick and never pushed any extra fluff during pickup!!! More
by Lino
Employees Worked With
Marc Humanitzki, Helga Carroll
December 14, 2017
excellent matt was very easy to work with and made the whole car buying experience painless, the way it should be. I asked him for his best price and got it. matt was very easy to work with and made the whole car buying experience painless, the way it should be. I asked him for his best price and got it. More
by rcapp4
Employees Worked With
Matt Trubia
December 11, 2017
Kind and Trustworthy! Chris Panepinto & Manager Frank Montalto are kind & considerate, respectful of my needs & my time, & they have earned my trust . They only fix what ne Chris Panepinto & Manager Frank Montalto are kind & considerate, respectful of my needs & my time, & they have earned my trust . They only fix what needs to be fixed. More
by MyZ3
Employees Worked With
Manager Frank Montalto
December 08, 2017
Good dealership It was a good experience. Theresa was very friendly and assisted in the whole car buying process. Keep up the great job!! I will be happy to recomm It was a good experience. Theresa was very friendly and assisted in the whole car buying process. Keep up the great job!! I will be happy to recommend it to others More
by Mdcarz
Employees Worked With
Theresa Pierro
December 07, 2017
Professional and Honest Recently bought a new car from Doug. He is very honest and NO BS. You don’t feel dirty when you leave the dealership. I went in knowing what I wanted Recently bought a new car from Doug. He is very honest and NO BS. You don’t feel dirty when you leave the dealership. I went in knowing what I wanted to spend and left with more than I thought I would get. BMW is always pricey but worth it. Highly recommended! More
by Rich R.
Employees Worked With
Doug Monette, Rudy Alanis
December 05, 2017
service for a pre-owned car - service was above and beyond Rudy at competition BMW made a difficult situation painless by correcting the issues and having the car delivered in time and picked up the provided Rudy at competition BMW made a difficult situation painless by correcting the issues and having the car delivered in time and picked up the provided loaner car More
by Pete Taylor
Employees Worked With
Rudy Alanis, Aschlyn Puterio
December 05, 2017
Great! Fun! Painless! I have only great things to say about Theresa. I just leased a new car from her; and had previously purchased a car from her. Theresa has an incred I have only great things to say about Theresa. I just leased a new car from her; and had previously purchased a car from her. Theresa has an incredible ability to match her customer with a perfect car. She can read my mind. Theresa works tirelessly to find my "perfect car". This is my third car from Competition BMW. I have nothing but praise for both the sales and service. department. It is the only place I buy and service my car. More
by bmurray1
Employees Worked With
Greg Box, Theresa Pierro
December 05, 2017
Service experience I have nothing but good things to say about my service experiences. Greg is always professional and concerned. He strives to do his best to quickly I have nothing but good things to say about my service experiences. Greg is always professional and concerned. He strives to do his best to quickly take care of my problem. I always service my car at Competition because of the kind, professional service Greg provides. More
by bmurray1
Employees Worked With
Greg Box
