Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Atlantic Hyundai
West Islip, NY
2,814 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 2,814 reviews
December 21, 2023
Ed Brightman is so helpful and goes above and beyond to get you the best deal. He is literally the only salesman I have ever trusted and I refer everyone I know to him. He makes the process as easy as poss get you the best deal. He is literally the only salesman I have ever trusted and I refer everyone I know to him. He makes the process as easy as possible and I look forward to continuing to work with him! Thank you, Ed! :) More
by Lindsay B
Employees Worked With
Ed Brightman
December 15, 2023
I just had a horrible purchasing experience at Atlantic Hyundai! Sandra Redway and her Sales Manager agreed to a price of $33,315 but when they wrote up the paperwork, they jacked up the price by $1,500. Hyundai! Sandra Redway and her Sales Manager agreed to a price of $33,315 but when they wrote up the paperwork, they jacked up the price by $1,500. Their digital lease agreement doesn't allow you to see the agreed upon price when you are signing the paperwork. Once I got home, I saw that they overcharged me. I gave them the opportunity to make it right but they decided to cheat me out of $1,500 instead. BEWARE of this dealership! Afterwards, they told me they lost money on this car but meanwhile they sold it to me for over the dealer invoice price. This proves they are dishonest and have no problem cheating their customers out of $1,500. Please don't give them your business. More
by Causeway68
Employees Worked With
Sandra Redway
December 11, 2023
Great experience, Iris really was wonderful and worked really hard to get us the car we wanted at the price we wanted. She kept us informed the entire time. really hard to get us the car we wanted at the price we wanted. She kept us informed the entire time. More
by meganmon
Employees Worked With
Iris S
November 24, 2023
We have been working with Sandra for 25 years over 12 car deals. Never rushes us, we talk and catch up. It's always like talking with an old friend. deals. Never rushes us, we talk and catch up. It's always like talking with an old friend. More
by halfpennyjm
Employees Worked With
Sandra Redway, Lekwa Nnate, Lenny Orlov
November 06, 2023
This is by far the most dishonest dealership I’ve ever been to. The promise you things and once you sign the papers to finalize the sale you are pretty much dead to them. I’ve been waiting 7 months for th been to. The promise you things and once you sign the papers to finalize the sale you are pretty much dead to them. I’ve been waiting 7 months for them to respond to my concerns and they are going out of their way to ignore me in the hopes I will just go away. That’s their strategy. More
by edd
Employees Worked With
Sandra Redway
October 20, 2023
Wayne Weinstein was very professional, courteous and knowledgeable. He went out of his way to help me understand my warranty and was very patient with all my questions. I consider Wayne Weinstein to be knowledgeable. He went out of his way to help me understand my warranty and was very patient with all my questions. I consider Wayne Weinstein to be an excellent employee and feel he should be recognized as such. Thank you very much Wayne! More
by bp631
Employees Worked With
Wayne Weinstein
October 17, 2023
Gary has been nothing but great to us! We have had him for several years now. He is kind patient and through during our whole process. We have had him for several years now. He is kind patient and through during our whole process. More
by antoniettafemm
Employees Worked With
Gary Calixte, Lenny Orlov
October 17, 2023
Gary is very helpful and provides superior customer service, my daughter and I both purchased vehicles and Gary made the transition smooth and stress free. service, my daughter and I both purchased vehicles and Gary made the transition smooth and stress free. More
by Claudiafemm
Employees Worked With
Gary Calixte
October 16, 2023
Gary was the BEST. He explained the process clearly and carefully. I felt comfortable and in charge of the entire purchase. I would highly recommend that you ask for Ga He explained the process clearly and carefully. I felt comfortable and in charge of the entire purchase. I would highly recommend that you ask for Gary to be your sales person if you go to Atlantic Hyundai to purchase a car. More
by jabbata2.0
Employees Worked With
Gary Calixte, Lenny Orlov
