Andy Mcquiston
Sales Consultant
City Volkswagen of Highland
9601 Indianapolis Blvd
Highland, IN 46322
Dealership Experience
12 yrs, 11 mos
441 Reviews
Write a Review441 Reviews of Andy Mcquiston
June 30, 2026
Andy was amazing. He clearly was very knowledgeable, he was very clear in his speech, and overall incredibly helpful. Great experience. He clearly was very knowledgeable, he was very clear in his speech, and overall incredibly helpful. Great experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Joe LeDuc
June 30, 2026
Andy made what’s usually a stressful process feel effortless. He was patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful from day one through my entire month-long decision process. No matter what question effortless. He was patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful from day one through my entire month-long decision process. No matter what question or concern I threw at him, Andy had answers and solutions. In the end, he delivered the exact car I wanted at a great price. Hands down one of the best car-buying experiences I’ve ever had—I’d go back to Andy in a second and recommend him to anyone without hesitation. More
Other Employees Tagged: James Thomas
June 28, 2026
Friendly, easy communication with staff. Andy was pleasant to work with. Love the car. Will recommend to others. Andy was pleasant to work with. Love the car. Will recommend to others. More
Other Employees Tagged: James Thomas
June 28, 2026
I also want to recognize Andy for providing an outstanding customer experience. Although I was working with Nik, Andy stepped in seamlessly while Nick was assisting another customer. He took th outstanding customer experience. Although I was working with Nik, Andy stepped in seamlessly while Nick was assisting another customer. He took the time to answer my questions, He and took my son and me on a test drive… we never felt like we were just waiting. What impressed me most was the teamwork. Andy treated us as if he'd been helping us from the very beginning, and that says a lot about the customer service culture at City Volkswagen. Even after I walked out of the door and got in the car, Andy saw that I still needed help because I couldn’t figure out how to connect my phone to the car and he came over to assist. That’s not just good Customer Service that’s genuine kindness. More
Other Employees Tagged: Nick Ferguson
June 28, 2026
Nick made what could have been a stressful experience feel straightforward and honest. From the beginning, he was transparent, responsive, and respectful of my time. He communicated clearly, answered feel straightforward and honest. From the beginning, he was transparent, responsive, and respectful of my time. He communicated clearly, answered my questions directly, and never made me feel pressured. I appreciated that he gave me the information I needed upfront instead of asking me to come into the dealership just to find things out. It's clear that Nick genuinely works for his customers and wants them to make informed decisions. That level of honesty and professionalism is hard to find, and it made all the difference. Thank you, Nick, for your integrity, kindness, and outstanding customer service. I LOVE my new car! More
Other Employees Tagged: Nick Ferguson
June 17, 2026
Andy was an unbelievable help was super personable and made everything easy and simple to purchase my first car. made everything easy and simple to purchase my first car. More
Other Employees Tagged: Daveed Allen, Jacob Bodnar
June 15, 2026
Andy McQuiston was extremely helpful during my visit. He was accommodating to my needs and knowledgeable with the cat details. I would recommend this dealership and ask for Andy! He was accommodating to my needs and knowledgeable with the cat details. I would recommend this dealership and ask for Andy! More

