Back

Maguire Automotive

Ithaca, NY

not yet
rated
1,081 Reviews

370 Elmira Road

Ithaca, NY

14850

Directions

By Type

1,081 Reviews of Maguire Automotive

January 13, 2021

Our first experience with Maguire was a good one! The deal was great, staff members were friendly and the whole process wasn’t too long. They tried to lowball us on the traid-in, but that’s true of every More

by Dennis
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Steven Manos
Jan 15, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Dennis, Thank you for your review and we appreciate giving us the opportunity to do business with you. Bill Hamelin GM

January 11, 2021

They did not have to help me but I did I got two brand new tires taken care of just because I just bought them and I got a flat one day and hit a pothole next they were able to help me get those covered u More

by Derick
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
RJ West, Zach Haskins, John VonGordon, Jasminne Ayres, Eric Curren, Bob Sullivan, Chelsy Carey, Shelby Overbaugh, Ken Hart, Ainslee Kearney
Jan 12, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Derick, Thank you for your feedback, and we appreciate giving us the opportunity to take care of your needs. If you need further assistance we are here for you. Bill Hamelin GM

January 09, 2021

Mike was very helpful and made himself available for all our questions. He was authentic and I had a very pleasant experience working with this dealership! Thank you. More

by Alan
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mike Kaufman
Jan 11, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Alan, Thank you for your positive feedback and we appreciate your business. The team here at Maguire Automotive care about customers and wants to provide you with an exceptional experience. Thank you again Bill Hamelin GM

January 08, 2021

State Farm recommend Maguire Toyota to me for body work. I got an estimate from Mark and had the work done. I picked the truck up 4 days later and everything was perfect. This is a new, clean and well orga More

by jmalger1
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mark, in the body shop
Jan 11, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

jmalger1, Thank you allowing us to fix your vehicle and we appreciate the positive feedback. We do our best to provide an exceptional experience and getting your vehicle back to you quickly. Bill Hamelin GM

Jan 11, 2021 -

jmalger1 responded

You are the best! Thanks again.......Jim

January 08, 2021

Great customer service. Friendly and knowledgeable service advisers. John Von Gordon is a pleasure to work with. We've been taking our vehicles to him for longer than I can remember. More

by PAK
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Connor, John VonGordon, Chelsy Carey
Jan 11, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

PAK, Thank you for your positive feedback and time to reply. We appreciate your business and hope to see you in the future. Bill Hamelin GM

January 08, 2021

There is a solid sense of authenticy from this dealership & the service department that feels too good to be true, yet they prove themselves to be authentic time & time again. More

by Jen Chiaino
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
RJ West, Zach Haskins, John VonGordon, Jasminne Ayres, Eric Curren, Bob Sullivan, Chelsy Carey, Shelby Overbaugh, Ken Hart, Ainslee Kearney
Jan 11, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Jen Chiaino, We appreciate the feedback and will continue to be authentic and just care about the people. Thank you for your business and believing in us. Bill Hamelin GM

January 08, 2021

From the moment I spoke with Mike Kaufman, I knew this salesman truly cared about making customers his number one priority! When I had numerous questions about the vehicle I was interested in, he went abo More

by Devinsn18
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Bethany Guernsey, Mike Kaufman
Jan 11, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Devinsn18, Congrats on the the new Truck and i hope you enjoy it for years to come. Thank you for allowing us to take care of you during this purchase. We appreciate your business and will be here for your services. Bill Hamelin GM

January 07, 2021

We worked with Steve Manos. We knew what we wanted going in and he helped us get it. Thank you for your help before and after buying the vehicle. More

by dmf39
Customer Service
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Steve Manos, Dan Halladay
Jan 08, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

DMF39, Thank you for your positive review and we appreciate your business. If we can be of any other service please reach out. Bill Hamelin GM

January 06, 2021

I worked with Michael while finding my new vehicle. He was educated, understanding, and overall a pleasure to work with! I ry appreciated all of his hard work to help find the right vehicle for me. He wen More

by Apalmer03
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mike Kaufman, Dan Halladay
Jan 06, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

Apalmer03, We appreciate your response and want to thank you for your business. Enjoy your new purchase. Bill Hamelin GM

January 05, 2021

I love this dealership. Consistent, friendly and competent service every single time. Great job on washing and sanitizing my car. Wyatt was great at explaining everything. I never go anywhere else. More

by JANET_BEEBE2000
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Quality Of Work
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Wyatt, Shelby Overbaugh, Ainslee Kearney
Jan 06, 2021 -

Maguire Automotive responded

JANET_BEEBE2000, Thank you for the kind words and we appreciate your business. Wyatt is part of an amazing team and supported by a great parts, service, sales and body shop like no other. Once again for giving us the opportunity to do business with you. Bill Hamelin GM

...
49
...