49 Reviews
Write a Review49 Reviews of Michael Fay
February 16, 2026
This is the second vehicle I have purchased from this dealership. Cochran Subaru Butler offered me the most value for my trade and gave me a fair price on the new vehicle. All of the people I have come dealership. Cochran Subaru Butler offered me the most value for my trade and gave me a fair price on the new vehicle. All of the people I have come in contact with, Sales Consultant, Sales Manager, Finance Consultant and Service team have been easy to work with and friendly. Dan O'Brien, Mike Pesci, Crystal Spreng and Mike Fay are all fantastic. My brother also purchased a vehicle from Cochran Subaru's Monroeville location based on my experience. I am very satisfied with the dealership and staff. More
Other Employees Tagged: Dan O'Brien, Mike Pesci, Crystal Spreng
February 09, 2026
I came in to purchase a new Subaru and was very happy with my experience. The staff were very friendly, and weren’t pushy about getting me into a higher range model. I have already recommended this deale with my experience. The staff were very friendly, and weren’t pushy about getting me into a higher range model. I have already recommended this dealership to a couple of people in the market for a new car. More
February 05, 2026
Great experience with all people we have encountered. Will recommend all friends and family here. Mike and Jim were a pleasure to deal with. Will recommend all friends and family here. Mike and Jim were a pleasure to deal with. More
Other Employees Tagged: Sales manager James is great
January 26, 2026
The customer service you have consistently provided is outstanding! We have a Subaru dealer much closer but we drive from Sewickley to you in Renfrew! Thank you for your care for us and our vehicle! outstanding! We have a Subaru dealer much closer but we drive from Sewickley to you in Renfrew! Thank you for your care for us and our vehicle! More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael McGlumphy
January 18, 2026
Good Selection of cars Great Great people to deal with and Very courteous I took my Subaru back for an oil change and was very pleased with your service department All Thumbs up and Very courteous I took my Subaru back for an oil change and was very pleased with your service department All Thumbs up More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael McGlumphy , Josh Connie with the service department
January 16, 2026
Fair deal and great customer service not much more to say, etc etc etc the end! say, etc etc etc the end! More
Other Employees Tagged: Brandon Fehl
January 15, 2026
Everyone was very warm & professional. Everyone was very knowledgeable & I was treated with respect with all of my questions. Everyone was very knowledgeable & I was treated with respect with all of my questions. More
Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Texter

