Dealership Experience
8 yrs, 2 mos
Industry Experience
8 yrs, 2 mos
1 Review
Write a Review1 Review of Caitlin Eldredge
November 15, 2026
I am writing this review two months after an awful car purchase experience at Copeland Subaru in Hyannis, having had time to calm down and accurately reflect on it. We drove two hours to buy a used SUV purchase experience at Copeland Subaru in Hyannis, having had time to calm down and accurately reflect on it. We drove two hours to buy a used SUV after finalizing a clear, written out-the-door agreement with their online team and sales management. As part of our negotiations, management committed to a credit for upcoming maintenance. Prior to driving the car off the lot for an independent Pre-Purchase Inspection, we discovered and pointed out to the salesman a star crack in the windshield near the safety camera -- damage that was never mentioned despite our repeated requests for transparency. When the car passed the mechanical inspection, we were ready to buy -- expecting them to take responsibility for the glass damage. Instead, management handled it poorly at every turn: • ADVISING INSURANCE FRAUD: The salesman and onsite manager told us to buy the car “as-is” and immediately file a glass claim on our own auto insurance because Massachusetts law covers broken windows (assuming you owned the car at the time of the crack). Filing a claim for pre-existing damage is insurance fraud. • CLAWING BACK A WRITTEN CREDIT: They argued that legally they did not need to repair the windshield because the chip was so small. Maybe so, but no reasonable person expects to buy a $20,000 car with a broken window that in a short time will turn into a safety hazard and needs to be addressed. They gave us an ultimatum: take it “as-is,” or they would fix it by making us pay for the repair – forfeiting the credit they had already agreed to. We walked away. • STONEWALLING: The online staff and manager who approved our deal in writing never stepped in or replied to our follow-up emails, even when we offered to split the cost of a local glass repair to close the deal. Four days later, the floor salesperson called the buyer directly and said that their position had not changed. • HEAVY-HANDED UPSELLING: Because the car had passed our mechanical inspection and the buyer urgently needed reliable transportation, they decided to buy the car and give up the credit to get the glass fixed. While finalizing the paperwork remotely, the finance office pitched and added a costly extended warranty. We have bought many cars over the years and understand normal negotiation, but advising a customer to commit insurance fraud and using pre-existing damage to claw back a written agreement crosses the line. We tried to get everything in writing and address every detail before making the drive, to no avail. Based on our experience, Copeland Subaru of Hyannis is neither trustworthy nor ethical. More
Other Employees Tagged: Keith Bertrand , Craig Martin

