Trevor Shay

I’ve been dealing with Flemington BMW for almost 37 years, one particular sales consultant to be exact. Now since his retirement I now deal with Vince and Cindy. I just purchased a new M8 and I couldn’ years, one particular sales consultant to be exact. Now since his retirement I now deal with Vince and Cindy. I just purchased a new M8 and I couldn’t be happier. I actually brought my daughters there and purchased two X3s. I was treated like family, as I in return treat them like family. Ed Kiley must be smiling knowing his customers are being well taken care of care of More

Report | Print

When I ordered an M3 Competition XDrive from Flemington BMW, I was told I would receive a $66,600.00 trade-in for my 2023 Audi RS5. I questioned the trade in value they offered, as I was told it would take BMW, I was told I would receive a $66,600.00 trade-in for my 2023 Audi RS5. I questioned the trade in value they offered, as I was told it would take 3+ months for the new car to arrive. I was told to keep the additional mile age low and as long as there were no accidents, I would get the promised amount. When the car arrived on March 25, 2025, they made me wait for about 30 minutes before I was to meet with the Business Manager. I saw her and asked what the holdup was and she told me they were working on the trade value. I mentioned that 4 months I waited, I only added 1,500 mikes and of course did not have an accident. It should have been a no brainer for them to finish the sales process. After 20 or so minutes, the salesman came back and said they could only give me $62,400.00 for the Audi. In my opinion, they knew they wouldn't be giving me the $66,500.00 trade-in from the beginning. When I wrote up purchase agreement, they did write in that if they didn't give me the $66,500.00 which was stated as a part of the agreement, they would refund my $13,500.00 deposit after they sold the car. While I don't think it will take that long for the car to sell, I texted the salesman I was working with if he could encourage the dealership to refund my deposit right away. He replied stating I signed the agreement knowing it would be reappraised and therefore my deposit won't be returned until they sell the car. at the end of the day, a great experience, buying my first BMW was a very disappointing ordeal. More

Report | Print

Got my 3rd Car from this dealer in 5 years, my family and I drive from PA just to do business with them. The process is smooth and simple. This is the first time I had Trevor as my sales guy, he did an awes I drive from PA just to do business with them. The process is smooth and simple. This is the first time I had Trevor as my sales guy, he did an awesome job. Catherine in finance is always great to deal with. And the sales manager Vince is a great guy to deal with. Great team in Flemington to work with I highly recommend everyone to get there BMWs from Flemington. More

Report | Print

Trevor provided exceptional service during my out-of-state purchase of an X5, making the process quick, easy, and completely seamless. His professionalism and efficiency ensured a smooth transact out-of-state purchase of an X5, making the process quick, easy, and completely seamless. His professionalism and efficiency ensured a smooth transaction from start to finish. More

Report | Print

Let's face it - I dont' know anyone who really enjoys the car buying experience. Lucky for me, I had an awesome experience. Trevor Shay helped me set everything up in my 2024 BMW x5i60 before I drove home. car buying experience. Lucky for me, I had an awesome experience. Trevor Shay helped me set everything up in my 2024 BMW x5i60 before I drove home. Cathy in finance was extremely knowledgeable and thoroughly answered all my questions. There was no haggling, we paid a fair price for the vehicle and it did not consume an abundant amount of time. Great team work! More

Report | Print

Excellent service from the moment we walked in. All employees helpful, friendly and welcoming. Do not underestimate Trevor’s ability of a sales person by his age. He is an exceptional young man All employees helpful, friendly and welcoming. Do not underestimate Trevor’s ability of a sales person by his age. He is an exceptional young man with incredible knowledge of any car, and is quite impressive with knowing everything little thing about a BMW. His professionalism from start to finish was excellent. Thank you for making our car decision easy! More

Report | Print

I stopped by in August to check out the 2025 BMW X3 30 xDrive. The base model was not going to be available until late September, and the M version was coming in two weeks. Trevor had followed up with m xDrive. The base model was not going to be available until late September, and the M version was coming in two weeks. Trevor had followed up with me at the end of September. I hope to come in soon to check out the new incoming model. More

Report | Print

Trevor was super helpful and patient and made the car buying experience smooth and stress free. Ask for Trevor. Mb car buying experience smooth and stress free. Ask for Trevor. Mb More

Report | Print

Sales person that I originally had, Greg, was very friendly and helpful, and was sad to see him go. Since Trevor was not there for the original sale he did his best to finish the transaction. friendly and helpful, and was sad to see him go. Since Trevor was not there for the original sale he did his best to finish the transaction. More

Report | Print

This was my first time using this dealership I was very happy with the way I was treated and would recommend it to others happy with the way I was treated and would recommend it to others More

Report | Print