Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Matthew Stickney
299 Reviews
Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. I want to enhance your overall car buying experience and provide you a great deal on a new or pre-owned vehicle. You can find me at extension 478.
Read moreDealership Experience
11 yrs, 4 mos
Industry Experience
16 yrs, 1 mo
Specialties & Trainings
Master Certified Commercial Sales Consultant
AFIP Certified
Masters Sales Consultant
299 Reviews
Write a Review
299 Reviews of Matthew Stickney
June 25, 2026
I have used Newins multiple times and they have always been great to deal with. This time was exceptional. been great to deal with. This time was exceptional. More
by kariszabo0
Verified CustomerOther Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty
May 29, 2026
Very non aggressive low pressure place. Very enjoyable, easy experience Tom is good guy great salesman. Very enjoyable, easy experience Tom is good guy great salesman. More
by captness
Other Employees Tagged: Thomas Siraco
May 22, 2026
Kyle liberty was a great salesman that ensured this deal was made, he is a pro! was made, he is a pro! More
by jesseang44
Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty , Joe
May 16, 2026
I could not be more happy with my experience at Newins Ford. Every step of the way was a dream. Everyone I dealt with was honest, courteous, and knowledgeable. I would recommend them to anyone buying a ca Ford. Every step of the way was a dream. Everyone I dealt with was honest, courteous, and knowledgeable. I would recommend them to anyone buying a car. More
by tamayer2002
Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty
May 02, 2026
Our fourth car from Newins Ford. Always a pleasure to deal with. That’s why we keep coming back. Always a pleasure to deal with. That’s why we keep coming back. More
by ngamble528
Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty, Bryan Blanco
April 28, 2026
Very good ? ? I aw very happy with Newins Ford Which is why I bought 2 new cars from them so far. This is the review that I posted on Google: I have had near ? I aw very happy with Newins Ford Which is why I bought 2 new cars from them so far. This is the review that I posted on Google: I have had nearly forty new cars in my life so far, but only two of those purchases were truly hassle-free and buyer's remorse was never an afterthought in either case. Well, both of those new vehicle acquisitions were made possible by the courteous and professional staff at the Newins Ford Dealership in Bay Shore, Long Island, NY. My most recent Newins purchase was made on April 22nd, 2026 when I was put behind the wheel of a brand new Mustang Ecoboost convertible. Sales Manager, Matthew Stickney and Sales Consultant, Tom Siraco were the two fine gentlemen responsible for making this happen and they could not have done things any better. My experience was nothing less than phenomenal and anybody who wants to buy a new vehicle SHOULD GET TO NEWINS FORD ASAP. Raymond Reis - Smithtown, NY. More
by raypreis
Other Employees Tagged: Thomas Siraco , Thomas Siraco
April 13, 2026
This is our fifth experience with Newins Ford and they continue to be a pleasure to work with! continue to be a pleasure to work with! More
by lmbutler1
Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty
March 08, 2026
Always a great experience dealing with Newins and Dan Salvatore. They make the process easy! Salvatore. They make the process easy! More
by acryan0
Other Employees Tagged: Dan Salvatore
March 04, 2026
Great place. Victor Aparacio was a great help. I was very pleased with the outcome of everything. I will definitely recommend this place to others and will buy my Victor Aparacio was a great help. I was very pleased with the outcome of everything. I will definitely recommend this place to others and will buy my next car here after my wife crashes this one first. More
by Raymondtthhhh
Other Employees Tagged: Victor Aparicio
