Dealer Reviews

Service Reviews

Cars for Sale

Write a Review

Dealer Log In

Write a Review

Matthew Stickney

Overview Reviews (264) Inventory (209)

Contact Me

View All Employees

< View All Employees

Matthew Stickney

Refer Me

Matthew Stickney

SALES MANAGER

Newins Bay Shore Ford

219 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. I want to enhance your overall car buying experience and provide you a great deal on a new or pre-owned vehicle. You can find me at extension 478.

Contact Me

4.9

264 Reviews

Overview Reviews (264) Inventory (209)

Dealership Experience

10 yrs, 2 mos

Industry Experience

14 yrs, 11 mos

Specialties & Trainings

Master Certified Commercial Sales Consultant

AFIP Certified

Masters Sales Consultant

View more specialties & trainings

4.9

264 Reviews

Write a Review

This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.

Contact Matthew Stickney

Name

Email or Mobile Phone

Message

By clicking Send Message, you agree to receive automated texts to connect you to this dealership employee, to market and provide information, and to better serve you. Purchase is not required and you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Standard message and data rates may apply.

264 Reviews of Matthew Stickney

March 20, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Newins ford was phenomenal. Kyle was great and my the process easy and enjoyable. I found Kyle to be honest and very helpful. I highly recommend Newins. Kyle was great and my the process easy and enjoyable. I found Kyle to be honest and very helpful. I highly recommend Newins. More

by douglasuss

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Joe Rivarola, Phil Calabretta, Victor Aparicio, Kyle Liberty, Dan Salvatore, Bryan Blanco, Kenneth Uss, Michael Giris, David Caselnova

Report | Print

Mar 21, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review. I'm glad Kyle took care of you. Bryan sales mgr

March 02, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Service and sales man did a great job went above and beyond good job to Chris beyond good job to Chris More

by richfazzz

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Report | Print

February 20, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Another great stress fee transaction with Master Sales Specialist Kyle Liberty at Newins Ford Bay Shore. I leased a new 2024 Bronco Sport Outer Banks while Newins bought out my lease at end of term. My g Specialist Kyle Liberty at Newins Ford Bay Shore. I leased a new 2024 Bronco Sport Outer Banks while Newins bought out my lease at end of term. My go to Ford dealer since 1984 with 13+ transactions through the years. More

by Chefpepe

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Kyle Liberty

Report | Print

Feb 20, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you so much for your kind words and continued trust in Kyle and Newins Ford! We truly appreciate your loyalty over the years, and we're thrilled to hear that your experience with us has been stress-free once again. It's always a pleasure to help you with your Ford needs. We look forward to serving you for many more years and transactions ahead. Enjoy your new 2024 Bronco Sport Outer Banks! Best regards, Matthew Stickney Newins Ford Bay Shore

February 12, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Great selection of vehicles. Knowledgeable and kind associates. Extremely fair business manager. I was dreading going car shopping but ended up a satisfied customer. Knowledgeable and kind associates. Extremely fair business manager. I was dreading going car shopping but ended up a satisfied customer. More

by taralynnshea24

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Dan Salvatore

Report | Print

Feb 12, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the feedback. I'm glad your purchase went well. Enjoy your new vehicle. Bryan sales mgr

February 01, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

My car buying experience with Victor was a smooth & pleasant. I would highly recommend this dealership!! My new Edge is fantastic! pleasant. I would highly recommend this dealership!! My new Edge is fantastic! More

by musicbrews

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Victor Aparicio, Bryan Blanco

Report | Print

Feb 01, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review. I'm glad Victor made your transaction easy. Enjoy your new edge Bryan sales mgr

January 30, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I had a pleasant experience at Newins Ford. They made every step of the process very easy. They made every step of the process very easy. More

by henriksen

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Report | Print

Jan 31, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review.

January 26, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Made the process very easy and straightforward! Great experience! Very happy with everything and the vehicle is perfect Great experience! Very happy with everything and the vehicle is perfect More

by Danny

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Chris Stickney

Report | Print

Jan 27, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for review. I'm glad everything went smooth. Bryan sales mgr

January 19, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

They were not pushy salesman and they did go out of their way for my purchase of my Mustang dark horse. way for my purchase of my Mustang dark horse. More

by r32skyine

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Victor Aparicio, Bryan Blanco

Report | Print

Jan 20, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review. Appreciate your business. Enjoy driving that dark horse. Bryan sales mgr

January 09, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I have been with Ford for many years solely due to the phenomenal customer service I get when I'm there. My dealer Rodney V is one of the coolest people I know and the staff at Newins makes me feel welcom phenomenal customer service I get when I'm there. My dealer Rodney V is one of the coolest people I know and the staff at Newins makes me feel welcomed and comfortable. More

by pedwards197

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Rodney Vera

Report | Print

Jan 10, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review. We appreciate your business and hope you enjoy driving fords for many more years to come. Bryan sales mgr

January 09, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

My dealer of choice. Great service, Honest people. Tom is the best!! Joe in financing is very helpful and knowledgeable. Great service, Honest people. Tom is the best!! Joe in financing is very helpful and knowledgeable. More

by joe@cyncalsteelfab.com

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Thomas Siraco

Report | Print

Jan 10, 2025 -

Newins Bay Shore Ford responded

Thank you for the review. I'm glad Tom & Joe were able to make it a pleasurable experience. Bryan sales mgr

Dealership Inventory (209 Vehicles)

2022 Ford F-150 | used

$39,990

2022 Ford F-150

used

Black exterior

10-Speed Automatic

4WD

$39,990

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2023 Ford Escape Plug-In Hybrid | new

$42,565

2023 Ford Escape Plug-In Hybrid

new

Red exterior

eCVT

FWD

$42,565

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2025 Ford F-150 | new

$54,190

2025 Ford F-150

new

Gray exterior

10-Speed Automatic

4WD

$54,190

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2022 Ford Bronco Sport | used

$23,995

2022 Ford Bronco Sport

used

Green exterior

8-Speed Automatic

4WD

$23,995

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2025 Ford Maverick | new

$33,050

2025 Ford Maverick

new

Beige exterior

8-Speed Automatic

AWD

$33,050

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2025 Ford F-350SD | new

$63,695

2025 Ford F-350SD

new

Gray exterior

10-Speed Automatic

4WD

$63,695

View Vehicle Details

View Details

View All Inventory

Had a great experience?
Spread the word.

By referring an employee you worked with, you agree to share your email address with this dealership so they can contact you should you qualify for their referral bonus. Qualifications for referral bonuses vary by dealer.

Matthew Stickney

SALES MANAGER

Newins Bay Shore Ford

264 Reviews of Matthew Stickney

Dealership Inventory (209 Vehicles)

Had a great experience?Spread the word.

Had a great experience?
Spread the word.