Back

Malloy Toyota

Winchester, VA

3.0
88 Reviews

400 Weems Lane

Winchester, VA

22601

Directions

By Type

Showing 88 reviews

January 30, 2025

The service reps here are very helpful. Got me the best deal to fix the garage guys error!! Thanks ladies! More

by Erniesledd3041
Service Price Transparency
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Elizabeth Lunsford, Gail Steele, Samantha Gregory
Jan 30, 2025 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear that our service representatives at Malloy Toyota were able to assist you in resolving the issue and getting you the best deal. We appreciate your kind words and look forward to helping you again in the future! Thank you, Chris Cokonis, Service Director

January 27, 2025

Hello, From the internet department, the salesman, the lady who showed me some options on aftermarket protection and the F&I lady who wrapped up the deal are all top notch professionals. The truck was cle More

by godswatchman34
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Samantha Fletcher, George Harman, Michael Helms, Tom Shields
Jan 28, 2025 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear about your positive experience with our team at Malloy Toyota. It's great to know that our internet department, sales team, and finance department provided you with the top-notch service we strive for. We're glad you enjoyed your Tacoma and that the effort from our detail department made a difference. Thank you for making the trip to see us, and we hope to welcome you back for any future needs! Safe travels! Thank you, Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager

December 12, 2024

I purchased a pre-owned Ram 2500 at Malloy Toyota Winchester, VA. as well as additional warranties and agreements (Prepaid Maintenance Plan, Vehicle Service Agreement, and Tire & Wheel Protection Pla More

by 19Powerwagon
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Zachary Newland, Jay Scaramozzino, Michael Helms, Mustafa Mohammed, Lorenzo Gonzalez
Dec 13, 2024 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for your review. We regret to hear that your experience was frustrating, but after reviewing what you have detailed it appears that we did try and resolve this issue with you by offering a full refund. We're sorry you had to deal with this frustration in the first place, but at this pointare not sure what else can be done to rectify this situation. If you'd like to have further conversation, please reach out to me directly. Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager.

Dec 14, 2024 -

19Powerwagon responded

As general manager I'd think you would understand the actual point here. When you sell a plan or contract of automobile maintenances, it is then YOUR responsibility that you uphold YOUR end of the contract. How is this not understood? If you can't provide the services that were on the contract, then maybe you shouldn't sell it to a customer. When I walked into your dealership, I received an attitude from yourself, as mentioned above in initial review, acting like I owe you something. Professionalism? After your Service Manager stated, "I don't know what to tell you." it is a Finance Manager issue. Zach, your financial manager stated, "I do not have time to deal with this, I am busy. That is for the Service Manager to handle." That's how you treat any customer, even more specifically a local disabled veteran? Absolutely unacceptable! You acted like it was my problem that the services could not be provided. I can assure you it is most definitely your problem! Instead of taking the opportunity and handling the situation in your finance manager's office, you chose to walk out and "disappear." When asked for your presence later that evening, you were "unavailable or nowhere to be found." When returning a second time that day and I come into your presence at the doorway of one of your finance manager's offices, you exited the office after the question. That showed you surely were not interested to help and assist your employees to resolve a problem. You're a "leader" and sets an example for your dealership? How do you think the "run around" and "not knowing what to do" response from your "managers" is acceptable? Just as an apology, excuses are all I received. Even after a customer has been there all day, you still cannot come to a conclusion that this occurrence and situation should be compensated for; (1) You wasted my entire day, over 6-1/2 hours, due to you not providing the services that were signed on the contract during purchase. Compensation? No. (2) The gasoline at 12 mpg used to go to a so-called service you provide which only is changing oil, [once again 54 mins/ 41 miles]. Compensated? No. (3) The tires are cupped now due to your dealership not being able to figure out how to rotate tires do to not having a Ram computer when it was serviced the initial time as well as this occurrence. Compensated? No. Where's your solution to these additional issues and circumstances? I'm sure you don't have one and your excuse is an apology that you cannot uphold your responsibilities. Once again, not my problem. All I received was nothing but an apology over and over which is only an excuse. You have a problem, you correct it. It's called responsibility. Why should I have to re-iterate what was mentioned in initial review for you to possibly understand my inconvenience YOUR dealership has created? So let me ask you a question. When I purchased the truck, I opted into the additional "Pre-paid Maintenance Plan" which is 6 services paid for at time of buying the truck. Your solution to this entire problem on the day of supposedly service on the vehicle, was giving me the services I already purchased when I bought the truck!!! How is that a solution? It's not. You act like it was a good deal that you (after an entire day) provide someone something they already should have received date of purchase. Unacceptable. You received your money and full payment the day of the sale under contract. Giving me a refund is not the correct resolution to your lack of responsibility. I find it odd how it was mentioned that when warranty issues are discovered under additional contract, you have a charge account with Safford Ram for repairs, but your employees stated Safford Ram could not rotate tires for this inability of your facility to do so? You could have stated "Sir, we will pay for those 6 services because you purchased the contract plans initially when you bought the truck!" Additional inconvenience measures as well as if this was you approaching a dealer with these issues, how would you feel? That vehicle is utmost important due to medical issues and complications. It is sad of your actions and subordinates involved as well. Once again, at the end of the day and all of this, your solution to this issue was to provide 6 pre-paid services that were initially agreed upon with purchase. I spent the entire day in Winchester back and forth between Malloy Toyota and Safford Ram because you do not know how to figure out how to service a truck that isn't Toyota but sold the plan and customer had already paid for. I have now wasted additional hours for you and others to realize this is not how sales and after sale customer service is to be carried out. Respect, responsibility, problem solving skills, and empathy are a few topics maybe you and your involved employees should discuss.

November 18, 2024

Jason Plummer was good for his word. I bought a used 2024 highlander that had overspray on it. I was concerned, but he assured me it would be buffed out and would feel like glass. More

by jkpest
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jason Plummer
Nov 19, 2024 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for sharing your experience with us! We're delighted to hear that Jason was able to address your concerns regarding the overspray on your 2024 Highlander and that you're pleased with the results. We appreciate your continued trust in Malloy Toyota and look forward to serving you again for your future Toyota needs. Safe travels in your new vehicle! Thank you, Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager

October 05, 2024

I’m done with Malloy Toyota because of the receptionists they have answering the phones, who can’t seem to get anything right. I have been a loyal customer for years, but today was the last straw. I called More

by Chris C.
Workmanship
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Tina Smith
Oct 07, 2024 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Hi Chris, Thank you for taking the time to speak with us about your frustrating experience and other concerns regarding your interactions with the team. We are truly sorry that we failed to take care of you in a way that shows our appreciation for you choosing to service with us. We will investigate what happened in order to learn more and prevent this type of situation from happening again. If you choose to offer us another chance, please feel free to reach out directly. Chris Cokonis ccokonis@malloy.com

February 05, 2024

Terrible experience after the sale. This is the worst dealership I have had to deal with anywhere ever. My vehicle was inspected but the tint was so dark I couldn’t drive at night and i More

by nathanG
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Hash
Feb 06, 2024 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for your feedback, Nathan. Here at Malloy Toyota, we pride ourselves on customer satisfaction, and your recent experience with our staff does not reflect that. Please contact me at your earliest convenience so that we can discuss this issue in greater depth. Thank you, Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager

May 09, 2023

Had quite a bit of work done to our vehicle we had bought privately and it was a very stressful situation but Lorenzo was very understanding and very helpful through the entire process. My husband and I are More

by Kathleenmiller84
Service Price Transparency
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Lorenzo, Action Marketing
March 04, 2023

I purchased a car here about a month ago. About 3 weeks after purchasing the car I started getting calls from the dealership telling me I owed them more money on my car. Which is obviously a More

by mojochops
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
James
Mar 06, 2023 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Customer satisfaction is one of our main priorities, and it seems as if we fell short during your most recent visit with us. We understand the car-purchasing process may be stressful and time-consuming, but our staff is dedicated to making that process as fast and easy as possible. If there is anything our staff or I can do to fix your experience, please do not hesitate to reach out to me directly. Thank you, Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager

August 25, 2022

Took our car for inspection, inspector found a list of things that we declined for them to fix. Got eveything fixed, took it back for reinspection as everything was working great. The car passed the inspe More

by jamiebrothers44
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Price
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Sam
Aug 31, 2022 -

Malloy Toyota responded

We acknowledge your review and are currently looking into the events you’ve detailed.

May 17, 2022

I put a $2,500 down payment on a new Toyota Cross in February. At that time I agreed to a price. The vehicle arrived about 2 weeks ago. The dealership marked up the vehicle $2,000. There was no ment More

by Connie
Customer Service
Friendliness
Price
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Trevor, Kari and Craig
May 19, 2022 -

Malloy Toyota responded

Thank you for taking the time to share your recent experience at Malloy Toyota. We want each customer to be completely satisfied upon visiting us, and the impression you received from our dealership is not okay. We would sincerely appreciate the opportunity to amend the situation, so please contact me directly. Thank you. Thank you, Jay Scaramozzino, General Manager (540) 678-1791

1
...