2022 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

N/A exterior

$29,990

Unlimited Motors Westfield

4.9

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

$29,990

n/a exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Unlimited Motors Westfield

4.9

Contact Seller

View Details

2022 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$30,870

D-Patrick Lebanon Ford

4.9

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

$30,870

pearl white multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

D-Patrick Lebanon Ford

4.9

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$37,500

Unlimited Motors Westfield

4.9

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$37,500

pearl white multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Unlimited Motors Westfield

4.9

Contact Seller

View Details

2023 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

$32,990

Ray Skillman Westside Auto Mall

4.8

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

$32,990

deep blue metallic exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Ray Skillman Westside Auto Mall

4.8

Contact Seller

View Details

2023 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$34,119

Preferred Auto Illinois Road

4.8

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

$34,119

pearl white multi-coat exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Preferred Auto Illinois Road

4.8

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Stealth Gray exterior

$41,995

Zeigler Subaru of Schererville

4.6

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$41,995

stealth gray exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Zeigler Subaru of Schererville

4.6

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

$26,980

Basney Honda

4.5

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$26,980

deep blue metallic exterior, white/black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Basney Honda

4.5

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

$26,500

Bachman Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram

3.9

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$26,500

MSRP: $28,950

deep blue metallic exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Bachman Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram

3.9

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Solid Black exterior

$27,995

Indy Wholesale Direct

3.7

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$27,995

solid black exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Indy Wholesale Direct

3.7

Contact Seller

View Details

2022 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

$29,145

Napleton Kia of Carmel

3.1

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

$29,145

deep blue metallic exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Napleton Kia of Carmel

3.1

Contact Seller

View Details

2023 Tesla Model Y

used

Pearl White Multi exterior

Not Priced

Bentley Indianapolis

1.8

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

Not Priced

pearl white multi exterior, black interior

All-wheel Drive

Bentley Indianapolis

1.8

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Gray exterior

$22,995

Ooley & Blackburn Imports

N/A

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$22,995

gray exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Ooley & Blackburn Imports

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2022 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

N/A exterior

$27,580

Toyota of Merrillville

N/A

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

$27,580

n/a exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Toyota of Merrillville

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2020 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$27,977

Indy Luxury Motorsports

N/A

2020 Tesla Model Y | used

$27,977

pearl white multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Indy Luxury Motorsports

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

$29,135

Ray Skillman Ford

N/A

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$29,135

deep blue metallic exterior, white/black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Ray Skillman Ford

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$29,995

Legit Motors

N/A

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$29,995

pearl white multi-coat exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Legit Motors

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$31,495

Northside Auto

N/A

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$31,495

pearl white multi-coat exterior, white/black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Northside Auto

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2021 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$31,700

Craig and Landreth Pre-Owned

N/A

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

$31,700

pearl white multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Craig and Landreth Pre-Owned

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2023 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Red Multi-Coat exterior

$32,888

Northside Auto

N/A

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

$32,888

red multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Northside Auto

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2023 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

White exterior

$32,998

CarMax

N/A

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

$32,998

white exterior, black interior

Automatic

Four-wheel Drive

CarMax

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2022 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Gray exterior

$35,880

R&B Car Company Warsaw

N/A

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

$35,880

gray exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

R&B Car Company Warsaw

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Stealth Grey exterior

$37,777

Northside Auto

N/A

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$37,777

stealth grey exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Northside Auto

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Solid Black exterior

$37,856

Gurley Leep Ford Lincoln

N/A

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$37,856

solid black exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Gurley Leep Ford Lincoln

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi-Coat exterior

$39,500

TNT Auto Sales & Services

N/A

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$39,500

pearl white multi-coat exterior, black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

TNT Auto Sales & Services

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2024 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Pearl White Multi exterior

$39,603

Toyota of Merrillville

N/A

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

$39,603

pearl white multi exterior, white / black interior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

Toyota of Merrillville

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

2025 Tesla Model Y

used

Automatic

Deep Blue Metallic exterior

Not Priced

Craig and Landreth Pre-Owned

N/A

2025 Tesla Model Y | used

Not Priced

deep blue metallic exterior, n/a interior

Automatic

Rear-wheel Drive

Craig and Landreth Pre-Owned

N/A

Contact Seller

View Details

Tesla Model Y vehicles for Sale in Indiana

26 Results

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

2020 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2021 Tesla Model Y | used

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

2023 Tesla Model Y | used

2022 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2024 Tesla Model Y | used

2025 Tesla Model Y | used