Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Mike Payne
Refer Me
14 Reviews
Happy to be born and raised in good ol Bflo. NY.... Love Lake Erie and spending time fishing and boating with family and friends. GO BILLs :)
Read moreDealership Experience
10 mos
Industry Experience
22 yrs, 11 mos
Specialties & Trainings
BA in History. "Those that fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.” WC
14 Reviews
Write a Review
14 Reviews of Mike Payne
June 01, 2024
Good people to deal with when purchasing a new car excellent knowledge of vehicles they are selling excellent knowledge of vehicles they are selling More
by JAMES.PAWLAK
Verified CustomerOther Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Dylan Guzenski
Helpful 
May 24, 2024
All the staff I dealt with were very helpful, efficient, and professional. I would recommend this dealership to anyone. and professional. I would recommend this dealership to anyone. More
by SS
Other Employees Tagged: Allen Williams, Trevon Smith
May 17, 2024
This was my third Camry, dealing with Allen and it was nothing but a pleasure very efficient and excellent sales person.. nothing but a pleasure very efficient and excellent sales person.. More
by Don226
Other Employees Tagged: Allen Williams
May 16, 2024
Excellent sales/service and finance ! They were very honest and work as a team. I will be back soon for my husband’s vehicle! They were very honest and work as a team. I will be back soon for my husband’s vehicle! More
by cyndymgonez
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman
May 12, 2024
Excellent car, fair price, and the salesperson was trustworthy. I have recommended McGuire to friends and family. trustworthy. I have recommended McGuire to friends and family. More
by gmanjones1313
Other Employees Tagged: Dylan Guzenski
April 15, 2024
great people to work with. great price for my tradein and excellent rate for my new lease. great price for my tradein and excellent rate for my new lease. More
by beagles1955
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Allen Williams
April 08, 2024
Great staff, answered all my questions. Best experience ever at a dealership. Worked hard to get me a very affordable vehicle. Best experience ever at a dealership. Worked hard to get me a very affordable vehicle. More
by beagles1955
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Allen Williams
April 07, 2024
Friendly sales people. Did not like being charged $150 for transferring plates. Other dealerships I have recently bought vehicles from charged half that price. I’m hoping Did not like being charged $150 for transferring plates. Other dealerships I have recently bought vehicles from charged half that price. I’m hoping to receive my refund owed after registering my vehicle without having to be persistent. More
by ANORTH58
Other Employees Tagged: Xavier Matthews
February 08, 2024
Cody helped a lot with my purchasing of my new vehichle. Everyone in the store was very respectful and honest which you wont get at a lot of shops. Definitely couldve sold me my car with a worn battery but Everyone in the store was very respectful and honest which you wont get at a lot of shops. Definitely couldve sold me my car with a worn battery but replaced it for no charge helped me through all the steps and didnt try to fineese me into anything. Very straightforward and helpful guy would absolutely buy from here again (best price i could find around as well!) More
by Jmcnulty885
Other Employees Tagged: Cody Herman, Dylan Guzenski, Xavier Matthews, Sarah Williams
December 05, 2023
Had a great time over at Maguire! Worked with Xavier who made the purchase of my Grand Highlander a breeze. Bri made the delivery which was seamless. Also big thanks to Mike and Ai fo Worked with Xavier who made the purchase of my Grand Highlander a breeze. Bri made the delivery which was seamless. Also big thanks to Mike and Ai for working with me! Be back soon for the next purchase! More
by Steven S
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Brianne Zaker, Xavier Matthews
Dealership Inventory (88 Vehicles)
